Featured letter Better way to understand candidates' vote totals

Print Article

As shown below, on April 2, 2019, candidates for the Beloit School Board received votes which were publicized in various media along with a percentage figure that is a candidate's total divided by the total votes cast for all candidates. These percentages are misleading and counter-productive.

John Wong, 2343 (21.18%); Megan Miller, 1791 (16.19%); John Winkelmann, 1749 (15.81%); Pam Charles, 1736 (15.69%); Phillip VanLandingham, 1276 (11.53%); Ami Christophersen, 1199 (10.83%); Torie Champeny, 900 (8.135%); write-in, 68 (06.41%).

Total votes cast: 11,062

Since each voter was allowed to vote for four (4) candidates (even though some presumably chose only three or fewer), the number of voters selecting candidates turns out to be far fewer than the 11,062 number (like perhaps approximately one fourth of 11,062 or about 2765). This lower divisor into the voting total of each candidate yields a more informative documentation of support. It produces a descriptive vote percentage for them in this instance that is four times the published figures. When voters can choose multiple candidates, the number of people voting divided into the total votes cast for a candidate is the important computation if we want to get a meaningful percentage.

So, the winning candidates wind up with percentages as follows: Wong (84.72 %), Miller (64.76%), Winkelmann (63.24%) and Charles (62.76%).

These figures document support for the candidates that is more informative than the earlier low percentages. This is important, because it shares a clearer, accurate description of what happened in the election, and it is important because it documents community support for our newly elected leaders. The earlier low percentage numbers did not do this. They were misleading. In fact, our winning candidates have backing from more than half of the voters.

Tom Warren

Beloit

The former Beloit City Council president and retired Beloit College professor's analysis is well taken, and we thank him for it. We will report accordingly in future elections. - WRB

Print Article

Read More Columnists

WALTERS: 'Dark store' reforms start to move

April 22, 2019 at 11:51 am | Legislators promise to act on the long-running "dark store" controversy, but they won't offer the solution favored by Democratic Gov. Tony Evers and leaders of the Wisconsin cities, villages and town...

Comments

Read More

Featured letter NAACP: Beloit schools' bridge too far

April 16, 2019 at 9:03 am | This community was just subject to an act of deceit and injustice that rivals anything I have seen. In a vote of 6-1 the (School District of Beloit) Board of Education demoted and demeaned the servic...

Comments

Read More

Featured letter Charles: It was our duty to make decisions

April 15, 2019 at 10:19 am | For weeks now, the Beloit School Board and administration have discussed the best way to fill an administrative vacancy at Fruzen School and provide the much-needed stability and support for staff an...

Comments

Read More

WALTERS: Changes sought in child support, custody process

April 15, 2019 at 9:16 am | A bipartisan group of legislators crafted a package of changes that would rewrite rules governing the emotional issues of child custody and child support payments when parents split up. Last year, c...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(608) 365-8811
149 State Street
Beloit, WI 53511

©2019 Beloit Daily News Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X